This creamy pencil eyeliner is available in five shades, all of which feature a smudge-resistant, waterproof formula. (Try a winged swipe of black eyeliner to achieve Ree Drummond's Pat Benatar-inspired signature look, for instance!) If you're searching for a great everyday product, Revlon Colorstay Eyeliner received the best overall for its waterproof formula, always sharp tip, and wide range of colorsfrom neutrals to jewel tones. Thankfully, in today's modern world, finding a quality eyeliner doesn't require a high standing statusor a splurge for that matter. If you're looking to blend or diffuse the liner for a smokier effect, opt for a gel formula. And that's really good, if you ask me. It's ophthalmologist-testedand formulatedwithout sulfates, parabens, or phthalates, so it's gentle on the eyes. A soft pencil liner is often best for the waterline, while felt tip pens make for great cat eye swoops. Now we're talking! What We Don't Love: It doesn't have the finest point for precision lines. "While sometimes we're looking for a pencil that doesn't move, we also might want something smudgy and sexy," makeup artist, Ashleigh Ciucci told InStyle. Yes. Otherwise I would say definitely give this eyeliner a shot, especially for the great price! Whether you want to keep it neutral with a classic shade or go bold with a little color, there's an option below just waiting to be discovered. The twist-up mechanical pencil ensures a precise tip for every application and its waterproof-ability is a notch above the rest. Haven't tried them for winged liner like a previous review so I cannot say how they are for that purpose. This innovative liquid eyeliner features a wheel applicator that lets you roll your way to the perfect lined look. We found the best drugstore eyeliner pencils around according to our Influenster community. Since finding quality, affordable eyeliners can certainly take time, we decided to do the legwork for you. The must-try formula is hypoallergenic, ophthalmologist-tested, and cruelty-free. available in more colors than you knew you needed, waterproof water-resistant and/or transfer-proof, Comes with a built-in sponge for smudging and blending, Ultra-fine tip is delicate and prone to breakage, Some reviewers say the cap can come loose and unexpectedly pop off, Soft, creamy formula is great for the waterline and lashline, Waterproof formula won't smear or smudge for up to 24 hours, Some reviewers say it's difficult to remove, Gentle formula is safe for sensitive eyes, Some reviewers say the product runs out quickly, Made with clean, skin-friendly ingredients, Some reviewers say the formula is prone to smudging, Has bright, bold pigments that are smudge-proof, Some reviewers say it can be irritating to eyes, Ideal for creating thin, fine lines with ease, Some testers say the tip can get stick in the plastic casing, Not as highly-pigmented as some of the other eyeliners on the list, Helps conditions and strengthens your lashes with each use, Some reviewers say the formula isn't fully waterproof, Some reviewers say the pencil tip can be difficult to sharpen, Some reviewers say the formula is prone to creasing. Eyeliners come in many different forms, each with their own unique benefits when it comes to control, precision, and ease-of-use. The site may earn a commission on some products. But a must have if you like tightlining or putting liner in your waterline. 15 Waterproof Eyeliners That Won't Smudge, Budge, or Fade, The 12 Best Liquid Eyeliners to Nail a Cat Eye, The 12 Best Eyebrow ProductsGels, Pencils, and More, The 9 Best Magnetic Lashes for Foolproof Voluminous Eyelashes, These 12 Drugstore Mascaras Are So Good You'll Ditch Your False Lashes, The 13 Best Eyeliners for Every Look and Budget, Out of the 28 Cream Blushes We Tested, These 8 Gave Our Cheeks the Best Glow, After Over 100 Hours of Testing, We Found the Best Under-Eye Concealers, 18 Eye Creams That Work Wonders on Dark Circles, Here's How to Prevent Your Eye Makeup From Transferring, Once and For All, The Best Drugstore Waterproof Eyeliners for Hot and Sweaty Summer Days, Why Everyone Is Ditching Black Eyeliner This Summer, The Best Drugstore Lipsticks With Incredible Color Payoff, 8 Ways to Wear the Double Winged Eyeliner Trend That's Everywhere Right Now, Everything You Need To Know About Applying Makeup For Your Eye Shape. Just be warned: You may never go back to the pricey products after lining your eyes with these. The ultra-smooth formula glides on for the easiest cat eye ever. Add a subtle splash of color to your routine with a flick of teal green. It's sold in seven shades, including two black variations and a series of gemstone-inspired hues. This cult-favorite liquid liner isknown for its smooth glide, slip-proof design, and waterproof formula. In the end, choosing the finish comes down to personal preference. The super-soft liner glides on smoothly and gives just enough time to smudge out for a sexy, smokey effect before it dries and sets for hours. . What We Love: The soft, jet black pencil is intensely pigmented for dramatic lines. Lauren Balsamo is deputy beauty director at Cosmopolitan, where she writes, edits, and produces all types of beauty contentfrom product reviews to personal essays and trend reports. What We Don't Love: This pencil is only available in one shade. What's more, it comes with a squishy grip that makes it comfortable to use too. This unique gel-pencil liner delivers the best of both worlds: a silky gel-like formula paired with a pencil-like fine tip. The quality is just amazing. If you're hoping to accentuate your eyes in a subtle way, it's time to consider this ultra-fine liner. JSYK, you'll need more than a few makeup wipes (think: an oil-based eye-makeup remover) to get this sucker off your eyelids completely, but when the most common complaint about inexpensive eyeliner is its longevity, that's not a bad problem to have. I highly recommend.". Finding the right pigment type (kohl, kajal, liquid, gel, or cream), and application mechanism (pencil, pen, felt tip, or brush) to match your comfort level and preferred style will make for easier application. The staying power of this drugstore eyeliner is impressiveonce it's on, it'll stay put for a full 24 hours. The marker is thicker than most liners and sits comfortably in your hand, allowing for better control which is especially helpful for more novice makeup do-ers. These are my absolute favorite liners for the waterline. No thanks. THE REVIEW: "This pencil applied smoothly and easily," writes a tester. A great option for anyone who wants to define their lashline and give their lashes a boost too. You'll need to wait a good 20 seconds for the pigment to set before any fussing, but once it dries that crisp liner look will remain sharp and defined all day. Matte liners offer an understated definition, while shiny and shimmery liners can create a dramatic, eye-catching effect. The great thing about them is that they are affordable. For felt tip liners, hydrating eye drops can help to recondition the brush tip and formula. Makeup products you aren't happy with can be returned to the store, if you're not satisfied take it back, even if it's opened. It stays well throughout the day but isn't completely smudge proof. Back to school necessity? Cobalt blue eyeliner is a fun throwback from the80s that looks every bit as stylish today. One endfeatures a teeny khaki brown point,while the other has an angled smudging tip. Type: Liquid | Color Range: 4 dark shades | Waterproof: Water-resistant. "It's so tiny and perfectly shaped that it allows even someone sloppy like me to get a perfect line every time.". But anyone can master the different eyeliner formulas with a steady hand, a bit of patience, and a makeup remover to fix any mistakes. "It goes on smoothly, can be built up into a thicker line if desired, and it stays where you put it.". The creamy formula blends without requiring aggressive rubbing or tugging, so you can smudge it out with the built-in sponge or layer it on without irritating your lids. Lauren Balsamo is the deputy beauty director at Cosmopolitan with nine years of experience researching, writing, and editing makeup stories that range from the best all natural foundations to the greatest cream blushes on the market. Ask any beauty editor or pro makeup artist and theyll tell you the same thing: theres absolutely no reason to be over-spending on an eyeliner. Here's a tried-and-true eyeliner that strikes the goldilocks ideal. Type: Liquid | Color Range: 2 shades | Waterproof: Yes. our process. If you're looking to achieve a smokey effect, you'll want to look for softer, creamier formulas that allow time for blending and buffing, but will also set so you're not left with a smudgy mess. There are also long wear and waterproof formulas that promise to hold up through hot days, sweaty workouts, or marathon nights. Drugstore eyeliners that are labeled waterproof water-resistant and/or transfer-proof are greatuntil it comes time to remove them at the end of the day. What We Don't Love: It requires a fine point eyeliner brush for application. THE REVIEW: "For the price, this eyeliner cannot be beat," says a tester. Eyeliners with super-fine precision tips should be your go-to if you like to tight-line, define your waterline, or are into thin, subtle lines. The only downside to this is since the packaging isn't clear you never know when it's going to run out. If you want even more TLC for your eyes, don't forget to try one of the best eye creams. The high-performing formula won't slip, tug, or go on patchy and it's made without any potentially questionable ingredients, like parabens, silicones, or PEGs. I have always been a huge fan of NYX because not only do they make affordable products, but they make products that compete with their higher end versions. Great price!! While the color selection is limited, the shades feature light-diffusing pigments which appear as a soft, subtle shimmer that, once applied, highlight the whites of your eyes for a more defined gaze. The most notable aspect of the pencil is its self-sharpening tip, which ensures you'll always have a fine point to work with. If you don't like to fix your make up throughout the day & you want to feel confident without having to look in a mirror every time you meet someone to make sure your make up has stayed where you applied it, this is the product for you. (Ree prefers abrush and potversion too!) Not only is this eyeliner pencil transfer-resistant and smudge-proof, it's cruelty-free and vegan too, meaning it's never tested on animals and it's made with plant-based ingredients. Eyeliner is a makeup bag staple for a reason: that seemingly simple line traced around your eyes makes a statement. The set comes with a pot of lacquer eyeliner and a brush for easy swiping. They're incredibly easy to useno matter your makeup skill leveland since they're silky smooth they never skip, tug, pull on your delicate eyelid skin. This top-rated formula (with more than 1,000 5-star reviews on Walmart) also comes in shades of blue, black, and white. This is my holy grail when it comes to eyeliner, that is according to my eyes. Type: Pencil | Color Range: 24 shades | Waterproof: No. THE REVIEW: "The applicator is really uniqueit applies like a felt tip liner but the tip is actually more like a tiny synthetic brush," reads a review. Win, win, win! Every item on this page was chosen by The Pioneer Woman team. Naturally, this chubby eyeliner crayon is no different. A single pass of any one of the three highly pigmented shades (black, brown, and teal) delivers intense color payoff. This gentle, waterproof eyeliner is designed specifically for mature lids. What We Love: The pigment gradually dispenses as you line for added control. If you fall head over heels for the charcoal liner, you'll be glad to know it comes in black and brown too. What We Love: The deep matte pigment is intensely bold at first swipe and holds up well to moisture. In that case, look for a formula that sets quickly and won't wipe away at the first sign of moisture. By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. The are really good and I just couldn't resist to get them all. The best part about this pick is that it's smudge-able for 30 seconds after application, so you can blend it to your heart's desire before letting it set. Everywhere I have seen them, they run for about $8. Most gel liners have great color-payoff too, so you don't need to apply and reapply for a bold look. This top pickhas an ultra-fine brush felt tip and a long-wear formula that promises to stay on for 12 hours. That's how good it is. What We Don't Love: The marker tip can dull over time. Type: Mechanical gel pencil| Color Range: 8 shades | Waterproof: Yes. Considering I've only had two in those two years, and yeah I pretty much wear makeup on an every day basis. Its free, easy, and fun. Easy is relative because it really depends on the look you are trying to create. These affordable, top-rated options can't be beat. They are super pigmented. What We Don't Love: The formula is not waterproof. It's better than many high end pencil liners I have tried.". These come in so many cute colors, I currently have to suggest Swerve (the standard black), Get Paid (metallic rose gold), and Honeydude (the standard nude). It's awesome for its price too, and you don't have to sharpen the little love. Drugstore makeup brandsfrom icons like Maybelline and CoverGirl to clean and vegan makeup brands Pacificamake some truly excellent eyeliners for a literal fraction of the price of the prestige brands. There's a reasonscratch thatmany reasonswhy this eyeliner is a beloved favorite among beauty professionals and novices alike, and earns the top spot on our list. Just know that once the pigments set (about 30 seconds after application) they'll lock into place for hours. Ahead, you'll find 18 of the best drugstore eyeliners you can find on shelves and online. What We Love: The liner is available in tons of colorful shades and different finishes. Forget your standard black and brown! Type: Pencil | Color Range: 23 shades | Waterproof: No. productslearn more about I like to use it as an eyeliner and a cream eyeshadow allover my lids too. "The real selling point for this baby is that it's beyond waterproof and doesn't pill. The vibrant range of ultra-pigmented liners are formulated with coconut oil which keep the pencil tips silky enough to glide along the delicate waterline without poking, tugging, or pulling. These formulas tend to be for more advanced makeup wearers. THE REVIEW: "It's got a great creamy but not too soft consistency," says a tester. Best Pencil Liner: L'Oreal Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner, Best Liquid Liner: Milani Stay Put Matte 17 Hr Wear Liquid Liner, Best Gel Liner: CoverGirl Ink It Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner, Best Longwear: Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, Best Cruelty-Free: Wet n Wild Mega Last Breakup-Proof Liquid Eyeliner, Best for Cat Eye: Maybelline Tattoo Studio Liner, Best Color Variety: Pixi by Petra Endless Silky Eye Pen, Best for Waterline: NYX Professionals Slim Eye Pencil, Best for Sensitive Eyes: Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner. It's Time For Your 2019 Influenster Final Four, New Concealers to Keep You Looking Wide Awake in 2020, 8 Eye Products to Help You Channel Pantone's 2020 Color of the Year, 5 Liquid Eyeshadows to Make All Your '70s Dreams a Reality, 10 Shimmering, Shining Pastel Products to Help You Channel Taylor Swift, The Best Products to Master the Colorful Eye & Brow Trend, 5 New Vibrant Luxe Palettes to Hoard This Spring, Mini Eyeshadow Palettes to Tote With You Everywhere. "I typically do a simple cat eye for my everyday look using this without any primer and this stuff lasts all day.". There are traditional pencils which require frequent sharpening to maintain a point, and mechanical or twist-up pencils with a gel-like formula that sometimes have a built-in sharpener. Theres a few things that are staples in our makeup bags, and a good eyeliner is one of them. Add a few drops of moisturizing eye drops (like Visine), then screw the end and shake well. The jojoba oil infused formula is surprisingly soft, so it glides over your lids and in between your lashes without skipping. "This pencil is super soft and creates nice density but it blends out effortlessly for a smoky liner look," she adds. I hope Pacifica keeps this one around for a long time!". This drugstore buy has been better than any other eyeliner I've tried. What We Don't Love: The inky formula has a longer dry time. For tight-lining between your lashes or filling in your waterline, this is the only liner you need. Voil, good as new! Experiment with your look by checking out these amazing (and affordable) drugstore eyeliners that'll make all your makeup dreams come true.
Sitemap 11