Based on our extensive research, the LAGUNA TOOLS MDCCF15110 rose to the top as the best dust collector money can buy. | Do Not Sell My Data
It does require 20A/120V service. Figured if it lasted a year, I got my $100 out of it. I do think adding a separator will add a bit of friction loss, so the guy at the woodworking supply store is probably right. We will discuss these factors below in this buyers guide. The best dust collector for you will rely on a variety of different factors. Pete has been working in the trades since high school, where he first developed a passion for woodworking. Hope my limited experience helps out in some way. It consumes very little floor space, particularly for a HEPA rated cyclone collector. The efficient design allows you to use it on wet and dry materials as well. Fascinated by all sort of tools, Pete loves reading and writing about all the latest gadgets and accessories that hit the market. Some can filter out tiny pieces of dirt, while others can only filter out dust particles larger than 2 microns. If you will continue to hook up machines as you need them, might want a 2HP machine and nothing larger. The size of the dust it can remove is unknown that stat is not provided by the company. I can do that, but trying not to. Otherwise, this dust is going to end up in your lungs or your tools engine. At the moment it looks like I will most likely go with the jet 1.5hp Vortex DC. Hear, hear! However that fine layer of dust that used to build up after every project is no longer there. Together, they can filter at 99.96% of all particles between 0.2 and 2 microns. However, some projects and hobbyists might require a portable dust collector. . Michael, thanks for the reply. Most importantly, dust collectors are used to remove dangerous dust from the air, which can damage your lungs if inhaled. Hello, I am in the market for a new dust collector, And looking for opinions, advise. So I am still in need of a new DC. - Have you physically looked at LxWxH or foot print of these machines? The important thing is the performance I now get is constant and good. I'd also forget about the pleated filter and get a shaker felt bag, instead. Note that it would be better than the Harbor Freight DC that I currently use, and may even be a bit better that the Jet Vortex I will most likely end up buying. in. If you mostly work in your shop on the same machines, you likely dont need a very portable air collector. I really got into the cyclone idea. Some DIYing homeowners are not going to produce very much dust in the least. I have overfilled my bin once and that was enough. The Jet JCDC-2 is an average dust collector. I would have to run another 220v circuit to go with the 2hp models. Have a Veritas cyclone lid collector set up for 12 jointer/planer and tablesaw and have never had any problems. Wood, your hand tools, you and a little know-how. Tell us what kind of woodworking operations you do and provide us with before, during, and after Dylos readings. This isnt the most durable option, either. And then maybe not. The OMG with a 10 foot flex hose (5 inch diameter) serves each machine admirably (I havent set up a hood for the lathe yet). Youre sacrificing size for a lower price. It has a filtration capability of down to 1 micron. I would only recommend largest DC you can afford when you have fixed location and fixed ducting in your shop. FWIW, Ive always thought Oneida was overpriced. However, the filter doesnt work well to begin with, so it isnt that big of a benefit. Latest Blog Entries |
- Plastic anything does not survive well in desert SW of Arizona. I would not want to go back to a bag only or to a filter cartridge without a separator. However, youll thank yourself later if you choose an option that is easy to put together. You have to have space to move it and it seems that that starts to add up to more space than it would take to just have it in place. So just 2hp is enough to grab pieces of wood off your saw. My small shop, one good DC will be fine. Inlet area (in sq. Some are incredibly cheap, while others can cost thousands of dollars. Sometimes I hear a block rattling along in the piping. Seems like the Oneida mini gorilla is the only one in the list that is HEPA filtered, that would be something on my checklist. And I do believe in the cyclones with the hepa filters. Using a jig is like having a couple extra hands helping out. Latest Projects |
I do not have any equipment to actually measure my CFM etc, however, I do have the evidence of my eyes and nasal passages. Then, the filter removes the smaller stuff. This machine does not clog very often, which is always an excellent addition. Preferably, you want a machine that can filter out particles that are lower than 1 micron. To convert to sq. The "smell test" is that 35% degradation simply does not seem right. The rated CFM is typically a pile of baloney. This would all be cart mounted and moved from machine-machine and should be able to keep a TS or planer clear. The Oneida AXD000004A is another inexpensive and very simple dust collector. This system is also easy to empty, so that is a plus! Eyes, ears, fingers, and Are you looking for or do you have tips to share regarding the workshop? So pretty easy to switch it. However, it is so cheap that you can purchase it again if it breaks. I would focus on rated CFMs and filters. The LAGUNA TOOLS MDCCF15110 is a huge dust collector. Im building a new shop and have a good Delta, 1100 cfm and thinking about getting another in lieu of running ducts and paying out 3k for one with duct work. a challenge, perhaps? If you are a carver or want Intarsia, fretwork, intricate design cutting and more! @daniel: As I noted, it would be a DD (or SDD), and only because it has been proven to be about 3% cleaner than a Thien baffle. If you are selling your work, then you have entered a woodworking dimension with added complexity and stress. However, with that low price, this dust collector is very cheaply made. There is nothing more important than your health, and having a quality filter is what makes the dust collector do its job effectively. Seems they all have issues of one sort or another. It just doesnt do its job very well. Different wood requires different woodworking strategies - from cutting to finishing. The SDD has a 5" dia. Again, this helps the airflow stay high. It can filter out tiny particles and have enormous capacity, making it perfect for those who want to stay as safe as possible. It may even be big enough for some professional shops. Looking at four models, brands at the moment. The Baileigh DC-1450C is a moderately priced option. YMMV but walk though the workflow a few times and see how much space is saved or taken as the case may be. You will be much happier in the long run if you spend a little time and $ on a 240v circut and a larger machine. Plastic stuff drys out, cracks, and break way too easy. Not only does dust get everywhere, but it can also be a health hazard. And I think it has a 30 micron bag filter, so not very clean at all. The larger particles like wood chips are put into the collection drum before they hit the filter. It's possible I could suck up a nail or a screw from the garage floor. Not to mention I was constantly cleaning a filter and ruining it by constantly cleaning it. You also have to consider if the pre-drilled holes match up and whether or not it comes with everything you need. Hear, hear! I have a 2hp cyclone, and overhead dc on both my tablesaws. I have a Jet 1 1/2HP blower fitted to a cyclone, its been running for almost 20 yrs with never an issue. The filter is pleated for extra durability, which is an excellent feature. It is effortless and cheap, which is most of its charm. Some manufacturers keep their impellers on the small side, sometimes for a good reason. It allows the machine to be much more portable, which is always great whether youre a homeowner or a professional. Looking for help with Are you unsure of which tools, or hardware, you need, or which brands to buy? Some have no issue with a 20amp. The C-Flux is larger than others on your list. Simultaneously, if you produce a lot of dust, you should probably invest in a more massive machine. However, it is decent. You may be tempted to ignore this feature, especially if you think youre a master at assembling stuff. I dont want to be rolling an even larger DC around my shop. This means more particles are going to be floating around the air youre breathing. Having difficulties reading project plans? The performance I got without the SDD was better initially but quickly became much worse as the canister filter clogged. I regularly forget the close gates on my Grizzly 3hp and it still has plenty of suction. You will only be assembling the dust collector just once. Saves rolling around and is very convenient. This is probably for me the biggest value of the cyclone -- blower insurance. A separator is total overkill if all you want is something you can connect to one tool at a time. It also isnt expensive for what it is. Latest Forum Topics. I have a 1.5 hp General rated for 1300 cfm, exchanged filter bag for a pleated cartridge and hard piped (4 PVC) shop. Could be that spending $200 on a self-cleaning canister filter is better than spending $200 on a small cyclone, if one has to choose between them because of budget. Personally, I am an advocate of no filter if at all possible. This forum is for scrollsawers: share your tips, ask questions Have a question? I have it piped in with 4 green sewer PVC and Lee Valley self cleaning blast gates to my table saw, miter saw, band saw, router table, and planer. The finish, whether paint, wax, stain, or something else, can make or break a project. I picked up the Jet 1.5hp Vortex DC. However, it is also a bit cheaper than comparative dust collectors. Note: This articles statistics come from third-party sources and do not represent the opinions of this website. 295651This is what I put together, we call it R2-D2. Comments and opinions welcome, thanks. Michael, thanks for the reply. Just have to keep an eye on the cyclone bucket. Plus my shop is a lot cleaner and there is less dust around the rest of the house too. Sort of love/hate. All rights reserved. Share your tips and challenges Before you pick up those woodworking tools, take the time to ensure your safety in the shop! ), including my 16 jointer/planer. This is smaller than most but is about average for the price point. BUT, most 240v machines are larger, heavier, and more challenge to roll around shop. I can say that my shop is staying MUCH cleaner than it used to. The two-stage filtration system has more working cubic feet per minute (CFM) than comparable horsepower (HP). We did find this dust collector to be a little less durable than other options. I measured my with a Alnor anemometer model RVA. It just depends on your budget and what you need. I will swap some sweeping duties over breathing in that fine dust any day of the week. That is a 25 cfm loss through all that hardware. Otherwise, it is just spitting dust-filled air back into the room. It is not made to last very long and is not very efficient. It is very inexpensive compared to other options. and a cyclone is probably overkill. This is a purchase that you cannot cut corners on, as it may damage your health later on. For those who dont want to spend much, we recommend the Big Horn 11653. I dont know the exact percent, my gut says 15% after putting my hand in front of the inlet. I would have to check, but seems I read that I need 10g wire to upgrade my 20 amp system. I pretty much knew that, just didn't want to get into it. The heavy debris is pulled down into the collection bin before the debris hits the filter. |
Multiply that times 4000 fpm and you get 545.4 CFM. Plus, it is so cheap that you can usually afford to purchase it again if you need to. It is a bit cheaper, but also lower-quality. in. In the end I ended up with a tool cluster and don't really move the DC much (unless I need to roll the BS to the front of the shop to do longer resawing in which case the DC follows). The assembly of this machine is complicated, though. satisfied that I am controlling the dust." Looking for information on designing your projects? ft. we must divide by 144 = .136 sq. Your money is better spent elsewhere, like in one of the other units we discussed earlier in this article. Unfortunately for me, the 1.5hp machines were at the top of my price range. Along with the Jet Vortex, give some serious thought to adding in an Oneida Super Dust Deputy cyclone with a collection drum. Anyone using a 1.5hp Cyclone DC out there?Trying to stay 110v which limits me to 1.5hp models. Powered by vBulletin Version 4.2.5 Copyright 2022 vBulletin Solutions Inc. All rights reserved. A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites in 2022, Oneida AXD000004A Dust Deputy Cyclone Kit, The 8 Best Cyclone Dust Collectors Reviews, Buyers Guide Choosing the Best Cyclone Dust Collector, 10 Best Retractable Air Hose Reels of 2022 Top Picks & Reviews. Still, we think this is a feature worth the extra investment. . For example, is the Alnor vane type anemometer versus a hot wire anemometer, best in this situation ? It did reduce the suction. inlet. You wont have to empty it much at all, and it is large enough to support all-day work. So with all that said. Reviews seem really mixed. For instance, it's clear that a single central collection system quickly hits a tipping point, at around 20' of pipe, that forces us to upgrade to a more powerful vac, which triggers bigger filters, larger ducts, a bigger cyclone, a bigger bin, more electrical capacity, more noise, and more makeup air -- ouch! +1 having 240v for DC solves a lot of problems and lets you pick best machine for your shop. | Copyright
I cannot remember, but I dont thing I used 10g when I wired the shop. So my questions are: 1) Does a cyclone really have that much negative impact on blower performance and 2) does a cyclone separator offer other benefits in addition to keeping the filter from getting clogged up? I just finished up adding it into the mix in my garage shop. After all, you dont have to worry about emptying the bin very much, since you arent producing very much dust to begin with. The cost of this healthy setup would be about $200. Hi Big JohnSorry to chime in so late, but got a new puppy 2 weeks ago and my days are consumed with watching her squat. What's "S&D?". . :-(, Please understand #IAMAKLUTZ and persnickety lunatic with wood working is my retirement hobby.Hence, YMMV, -- If it wasn't for bad luck, I wouldn't have no luck at all, Doom, despair, agony on me - Albert King - Born Under a Bad Sign released 1967. How to fix a messed up table-top panel? So if a 30 amp upgrade is really necessary to stay 110v. They don't wear out and some, like mine, filter down to 1-micron. And most are when machine has been in use a short time. The SDD really works very well in tandem with the Jet. Did your other one die, or are you going go run two. I use a cyclone on my shop vac and I rarely need to empty the vacuum itself. As you might imagine, it is also the perfect budget option. = 19.63 sq. Yep. | Privacy Policy
Plus, it is made in America if that is a metric that is important to you. So anything is going to be an upgrade. It's all good unless my wife decides she wants to fry a turkey and can't find her aluminum fry pot:eek: There is more to it than just increasing the size of the impeller. Dust can get in your lungs and mess them up. The dangerous stuff is typically not captured by mucous in the nasal passages, etc. And a blast gate to Tee off it to another hose to attach to all the other tools as needed. . And the added cost of a second 220v circuit doesnt help that. Dust collectors can be expensive, though. https://www.jettools.com/us/en/p/jcdc-1-5-cyclone-dust-collector-1-5hp-115v/717515, https://lagunatools.com/classic/dust-collectors/c-flux-1/, https://www.grizzly.com/products/Grizzly-1-1-2-HP-Portable-Cyclone-Dust-Collector/G0860, https://www.oneida-air.com/dust-collectors/personal-shops/1-5-hp-mini-gorilla-cyclone-dust-collector. Two-stage definitely works! TBH the increased size of the cyclone machines is a key reason I dont have one. Hey there Chris, #1 Unless I'm confused about another site, this thread did touch on particulate size a few times. If you wont be moving, you can start to invest in permanent steel duct around your shop. And one big tool at a time. As you imagine, this helps the filter last longer and also makes it work better. But they have turned out to be to pricey for my budget. Youd be surprised by the number of dust collectors that require you to purchase screws. One small negative about this machine is that users say it is a bit noisy. A big one seems to be the need for a 30 amp breaker. A short cyclone/cone are are not good for sucking fine dust from drum or wide belt sanders so if you have a sander or thinking about it these may not be a good choice? My table saw is the only real stationary tool. Storm & Drain? I once "accidentally" sucked a rather large, thick towel into my system. While there are many different dust collectors on the market, cyclone dust collectors are about as influential as they get. Not only will this decrease the number of times you need to empty it, but larger machines also tend to have better filters. I don't have any metal cutting tools to try to make my own. Without being argumentative here, I just get irked at how this dust collection business spirals so easily out of hand. DISCLAIMER: Any posts on LJ are posted by individuals acting in their own right and do not necessarily reflect the views of LJ. However, this also comes at a lower price. It can also damage your tools, especially those with sensitive motors. We expect that it isnt that awesome, considering the low-quality of the filter. Hello, My old Harbor Freight DC is still chugging along. Its not the most powerful DC ever of course so I still get some chips on the floor from the planer and the router table. And it got me started. Sometimes I notice a strip of wood I'm cutting off the edge of the board go whizzing up the hose. AN ELITE CAFEMEDIA LIFESTYLE PUBLISHER. His other interests include astronomy, hiking, and fishing. Generally, it seems people readily accept that it's the small particulates that are a health concern, and this seems to point to most informed people pursuing a 1 micron level of filtration, however, 0.5 microns seems to be a recent option circulating about the wood blogosphere. Eventually this will roll into the cyclone plumbing. I have spent some time recently on Bill Pentz site, and he says you need at least a 15" impeller to have a healthy dust system. Is that offset by: @daniel: As I noted, it would be a DD (or SDD), and only because it has been proven to be about 3% cleaner than a Thien baffle. frustrations? so cross-sectional area = pi X 2.5 sq. Best Luck! Then, the filter handles the smaller particles. This isnt as good as we would like. Despite the theory that cyclones and the like keep filters clog free, in my experience, it's easy to overfill the preseparator, or to suck down something that clogs the funnel hole momentarily. After years of chronic sinus infections along with the loss of my sense of smell as a result years ago I upgraded this year to an Oneida Supercell and the difference is amazing. Use the black plastic contractor bags; way cheaper than the clear ones made for DC's. It can be used many times without breaking. If I did not have to breathe my return air I would use a bagger and just vent outside. In either of these cases, everything then starts going to the filter until I realize what I've done. And I do like its added features. What's "S&D?" This is the primary reason we recommend this dust collector so heavily it can collect practically all the dust in your workspace. If I were doing it all over again, I would buy a HF 1hp - 2hp DC (~650 cfm and as low as $99) + 1micron bag from Rockler ($25 on sale now) + a Dust Deputy (on a big can) and use a hose no longer than 6' - 7'. This particular configuration has always impressed me: You gotta be sure the filters are really effective and be really diligent about cleaning them. Some dust collectors are small and portable. So, having an easy means to clean the filter is a good thing in any case. This is one of the significant reasons this dust collector is rated so low on our list. Usually, size and quality are directly related to the price. Bradley. I was thinking of putting together a small tower configuration on a shop-built rolling stand using a 1.5HP 850CFM blower mounted atop either an Oneida Super Dust Deputy (the new plastic one with 6" inlet and sloped ramp) or a no-name sheet metal cyclone available online. None of your list has large enough casters for my shop. Stumpy Nubs Woodworking Journal- For woodworkers of all levels (part 6), Repair oil finish on oak kitchen countertops. however, I do have the evidence of my eyes and nasal passages." It is more expensive than most other options on the market. It also has a wireless remote control, which you may find helpful in some situations. Right next to it was the Powermatic version. So I have discovered that the 1.5hp cyclones lack in performance. This isnt as small as other options. It is versatile and can be used with a variety of hoses and fittings. There is one significant downside of the Shop Fox W1823 is that it can only filter out particles that are 2 microns and larger. I think Fred's readings may have been taken on either side of the SDD. . Of course, your budget also plays a role here. This is only really suitable for small shops, though, and homeowners. I doubt the rating will be as good as claimed! The impact versus the benefit is up to you. The size of the area youre using the dust collector in also matters. Not if you want to spend more time wood working than dust collector cleaning. It is essential to choose the best option for your workspace and preference. This is my second post to your question, I misplaced the first one. So the cyclone does keep all that stuff out of your impeller. That's an impressively small cost for the upgrade; are yours pretty short runs? Some are incredibly portable, while others arent at all and require a team of people to move. My 2-car garage shop shares space with a mid-size SUV, and everything but the wood lathe is on wheels or mobile bases, so fixed ducting and serving multiple machines (theres only me in there anyway) are not necessary or workable. A cool $2499.00. I have an older Jet 1100 without the vortex. However, this is, without a doubt the best model on the market. However, that doesnt mean cyclone dust collectors are perfect. Do this enough and it becomes necessary to clean the filter. This dust collector is good, but it just cant beat out the LAGUNA TOOLS MDCCF15110 Dust Collector. I do not recommend going without it. Dust collectors vary a lot in cost. Having live with it for ~3 years now I'm not as convinced. LOL, have to be careful when using a 4 flex hose for clean up as it will suck up large chunks of wood(24 cut offs). I have a Jet 1200 with the Super Dust Deputy (SDD) and measured off the 6" inlet 5700 fpm/1114 cfm. It just depends on how much room you have in your space to spare. I've been shopping for a single-tool, short-hose, small footprint, ultra-portable, dust-collection solution. There is a relationship between impeller size and CFM for sure, generally the larger the impeller the more CFM. Share your "joinery" discussion here. DC-1100VX-CK back in late August from Home Depot for $675. However, this one may be purchasable on the average budget. Your woodworking skills are displayed for several lifetimes in each project. Different dust collectors have different levels of portability. For those on a budget, the Big Horn 11653 is the best cyclone dust collector for the money. Need a break from all the standing and wood dust? First- start looking for another woodworking supplier- that guy knows diddly squat. This is a very personal factor that goes into choosing the best collector for your needs. I have no hard data to back my claims up, but, a Thien style top hat separator works great with my 1.5 hp steel city DC. This does have something to do with the amount of dust you create more machines will likely lead to more dust being created. a tip/strategy to share? But open to others. If you want to protect your lungs, it is a small price to pay. If you have plenty of money to spend on a dust collector, then the Jet JCDC-3 is a reliable option. Questions and answers about CNC machines, tooling, best practices, and projects. Similar to our last option, this one has a two-stage separation system. They are very large-volume and they can separate heavy chips and fine dust from the air. View Full Version : "you don't want to buy a cyclone separator". If you spend a lot of time DIYing or are a professional, this is a huge plus. Will consider one after fellow AZ outdoor shop shows me one used for 10 years. Mine is not that big, and I have been trying to figure out the least expensive way to upgrade. My wife likes that. Also keep your hose diameter full size and reduce down at the tool (not at the collector). So yes, it does keep the filter from clogging up. A flapper will get the filter sorta clean but, a cyclone will prevent this in the first place (unless, like myself and others, you overfill the barrel :o). It also has a polyester spun bond pleated filter, which helps the airflow to remain very high. Saw the latest Jet at wood working store and they have cost reduced the support frame and is using plastic? Assembly instructions were excellent, and I put it together easily by myself. You probably wont use it as much, even if it is a nice perk. We found this simple system very durable, which is not something we expected to say! Currently using a tired Harbor Freight 2hp DC. If I were getting a new system and had to breathe the return air a cyclone would be a must. Scientific I know. Terms of Service
As the founder of House Grail, Pete's primary goal is to help consumers make educated decisions about DIY projects at home, in the garage, and in the garden. So it is my intent to pick it up when the next sale starts. I bought that DC used back in 2013 with the intent to upgrade it in a year or so. It may be out of budget for some. 2022 Verticalscope Inc. All Rights Reserved. With that said, though, it is essential to consider precisely what your budget is before you start shopping. :-). Sounds like a guy on a used car lot to me. Ducting is the real hidden expense in DC systems, and my approach 100% eliminates it; plus if and when you tire of moving the dust cart around a big shop (jeez I wish I had that problem), then just add another one to the other side of your shop to ease the carting about and you will still be more than $1K - $2K richer. And as I mentioned above. tips? If so, that is not the loss being described by the salesman. Cyclone systems are designed around this whereas adding a separator just adds an unexpected hit of some degree. Brazil is one of the worlds most beautiful. It never loses suction and works on everything from my ROS to the 13 inch planer. At the same time, your workspace affects the size of the dust collector you could reasonably accommodate. No way I would ever go back to no preseparator. Now you need to ask yourself what happens to that ASRAE rating when you try to push 545 CFM through a filter media that is rated at 11 fpm (amd what happens to CFM when you try to push it through that filter). It is a step down from our premium option. I used a Thien style before I got my SDD. But I would like cleaner air in my shop too. Finally, someone observes that anecdotal evidence under uncontrolled circumstances typically does not provide much useful information. There are no cheap and easy decisions to picking best dust collection. I feared it would wrap itself violently around my impeller and burn up my bearings and or motor despite turning it off ASAP. Thats only one reason why my proposed system will 100% eliminate pipe runs.
Sitemap 14